Retro pop culture, classic rock, pro wrestling history, comics, toys, television, movies and podcasts from Karl & Tonya. Home of historian and author Karl Stern's extensive professional wrestling history research.
The Latest from When It Was Cool!
Feature Article: 10 Greatest Forgotten TV Shows of the (Mostly) 1980s!
Join Karl Stern and When It Was Cool for a look back at some hidden gems from the late 1970s and 1980s. Crazy TV cops, superheroes without instruction manuals, dudes that turn into cars or something, Bigfoot (of course), and other whacked out ideas made the 1980s are wild and weird time for retro pop culture television! Read More
MORE NEW TODAY:
09-21-2026: 1980’s Pro Wrestling Star Ricky Morton Turns 70 Years Old
09-21-2026: 40 Years Ago Today in Pro Wrestling History (1986)
09-21-2026: Changes are Coming to When It Was Cool [Patreon]
MORE NEW FROM WHEN IT WAS COOL:
09-20-2026: 1000 Hours Podcast: The Retirement of William Muldoon
09-20-2026: This Day in Pioneer Era Pro Wrestling History: September 20
09-19-2026: Carrot Top Hospitalized in Las Vegas Following Reported Suicide Attempt
09-19-2026: Saturday Retro Wrestling Podcast: August 2013 Mailbag from Wrestling Observer Talking TNA, Jackie Fargo, Ronnie James Dio and More. [Patreon]
Latest Free Podcasts (Join Patreon for more!)
201 Greatest Pro Wrestlers of All Time List: Who Are the Greatest Pro Wrestlers of All Time
Compiled By: Karl Stern Sourcing Data from over 30 Historians, Vetted Greatest Wrestler of All Time Lists, Major Media Rankings, Cumulative Lists, and Major Vetted Halls of Fame. This list is not my opinion. The only input I had into ranking this list was doing the math and averaging the results and putting it together in a readable format. This, according to multiple respected pro wrestling historians, major media rankings, published books, and vetted rankings are the 201 greatest pro wrestlers of all time, with bonus points given for major vetted Halls of Fame and Wrestler of the Year Awards. Read More.
