Join us as we take a look at the history of pro wrestling pre-1900 or prior to the Frank Gotch era of wrestling. How did modern entertainment style pro wrestling begin and evolve? This series explores it’s history and personalities. YOU CONTROL THIS SERIES! It will only run as long as it is supported. In order to get another hour of 1000 hours we need a new Patreon supporter at any level or a cash donation via the front page of WhenItWasCool.com to either PayPal or CashApp (Please put “1000” in the note). As soon as it is received, I will produce a new hour. Presently, we are funded up to hour 144.
Hour 144: To be determined (Daniel G)
Hour 143: To be determined (Famikon D)
Hour 142: To be determined (Joshua S)
Hour 141: To be determined (David B)
Hour 140: To be determined (Justin H)
Hour 139: To be determined (Matthew A)
Hour 138: To be determined (Antpepe)
Hour 137: To be determined (Paul R.)
Hour 136: To be determined (Mmbakhtin)
Hour 135: To be determined (Fighter Fans)
Hour 134: To be determined (Greg)
Hour 133: To be determined (Awunyo-Akaba)
Hour 132: To be determined (Brian)
Hour 131: To be determined (Jeff R)
Hour 130: To be determined (Peter G)
Hour 129: To be determined (Brian B)
Hour 128: To be determined (Gene J)
Hour 127: To be determined (Greg H)
Hour 126: To be determined (David P)
Hour 125: To be determined (Jane R)
Hour 124: To be determined (Brad B)
Hour 123: To be determined (Peter N)
Hour 122: To be determined (Greg H)
Hour 121: To be determined (Greg H)
Hour 120: To be determined (Jay R)
Hour 119: To be determined (Liam F)
Hour 118: To be determined (Dr. B)
Hour 117: To be determined (HBKSweden)
Hour 116: To be determined (Joshua D)
Hour 115: To be determined (Joseph W)
Hour 114: To be determined (Eric H)
Hour 113: To be determined (Gregory M)
Hour 112: To be determined (Joe O)
Hour 111: To be determined (Michael D)
Hour 110: To be determined (Brian)
Hour 109: To be determined (Shaun O)
Hour 108: To be determined (Adam J)
Hour 107: To be determined (Todd)
Hour 106: To be determined (K Räisänen)
Hour 105: To be determined (Dave)
Hour 104: To be determined (Joshua D.)
Hour 103: To be determined (Eric L.)
Hour 102: Trouble Follows William Muldoon
Hour 101: William Muldoon and Hulk Hogan Had a Lot in Common
Hour 100: William Muldoon was a Civil War Fraud
Hour 99: Pioneer Era Mailbag Q&A Show
Hour 98: The End of the Pioneer Era of Pro Wrestling
Hour 97: McLeod Defeats Burns
Hour 96: That Didn’t Go as Planned
Hour 95: The Last Match of William Muldoon
Hour 94: William Muldoon the Con Man
Hour 93: The Return of William Muldoon
Hour 92: The Original Strangler Lewis was a Heel
Hour 91: Pro Wrestling’s First Business Slump was 1886
Hour 90: The Rise of Lewis, The Fall of Muldoon
Hour 89: The death of Clarence Whistler & Lewis Becomes Strangler
Hour 88: Muldoon & Sorakichi Head to Court
Hour 87: William Muldoon verses Col. James H. McLaughlin!
Hour 86: Return of McLaughlin/Strange Story
Hour 85: Muldoon Makes a Run For It!
Hour 84: Muldoon, Whistler, and Dinnie
Hour 83: William Muldoon vs Donald Dinnie 1883
Hour 82: The Poisoning of Tom Connors
Hour 81: Who Was Homer Lane and More
Hour 80: The Rise of Catch-as-Catch-Can Wrestling
Hour 79: Muldoon and Whistler Get into a Fist Fight
Hour 78: The Muldoon Tour Begins
Hour 77: Why should we study pre-1900s wrestling
Hour 76: H.M. Dufur’s First Reign as Champion
Hour 75: There is a New Champion!
Hour 74: The Pioneer Era Explodes!
Hour 73: And Now They Have Swords
Hour 72: Along Came the Bears
Hour 71: The Horse Lifting Incident
Hour 70: Birth of Sports Entertainment is 1870
Hour 69: Drunker Than a Musicians Dog
Hour 68: Monster Classical & Geological Hippodrome
Hour 67: Col. James. H. McLaughlin: Undisputed Champion
Hour 66: The Most Monumental Moment of the Pioneer Era
Hour 65: The Life and Crimes of Uzile Prickett
Hour 64: The Players Are on the Field
Hour 63: Wrestling Gets Organized
Hour 62: America’s First Wrestling Star Revisited
Hour 61: The Bible of the Pioneer Era of Wrestling
Hour 60: 1886: A Year of Change in Pro Wrestling
Hour 59: More Milo to Londos: Fact vs Fiction
Hour 58: From Milo to Londos: Fact vs Fiction
Hour 57: Real Terrible Turk and Muldoon vs Whistler
Hour 56: More Muldoon
Hour 55: The Truth of William Muldoon… Mostly
Hour 54: Will the Real Christol Please Stand Up?
Hour 53: McMahon-Owens Family, McMahon verses McLaughlin
Hour 52: Why Does Lucian Marc Only Have 3 Fingers?
Hour 51: Germany, France, and Europe in the Pioneer Era
Hour 50: The Man Who Derailed McLaughlin - Jacob Martin
Hour 49: John McMahon Shot, Davy Crockett Wrestling, more
Hour 48: Return of the Terrible Turk
Hour 47: Who Was Homer Lane?
Hour 46: The True Story of the Detroit International Tournament
Hour 45: Pioneer Era Wrestling in Australia / New Zealand
Hour 44: The Presidents in the Pioneer Era
Hour 43: Pioneer Era Great Lakes
Hour 42: Wrestling in the Biblical Era
Hour 41: Wrestling in the Russian Empire pre Hackenschmidt
Hour 40: Strongmen of the Pioneer Era
Hour 39: The Evils of Wrestling
Hour 38: Barney Smith is Dead
Hour 37: Showmanship in pioneer era France
Hour 36: Bounty on Barney Smith
Hour 35: More on King of Wrestling Charles
Hour 34: Who was King of Wrestling Charles?
Hour 33: G.W. Flagg and John McMahon
Hour 32: Pioneer Era Pensacola Wrestling and the Champion of the South
Hour 31: Of Bauer and Bears and more
Hour 30: Can We Bear Another Episode?
Hour 29: From Roman Reigns to William Muldoon
Hour 28: A Wrestler and Boxer Walk Into a Bar…
Hour 27: Story of Richard K. Fox: Pro Wrestling Influencer
Hour 26: Ringside Wrestling Book on the Pioneers
Hour 25: The Polish Influence on Pro Wrestling
Hour 24: More Col. James H. McLaughlin Killing Barney Smith Mystery
Hour 23: Pioneer Era New York outside NY City
Hour 22: Pioneer Era Lucha Libre: Mexico
Hour 21: The Mystery of Barney Smith. Maybe Dead. Maybe Not.
Hour 20: Champion Wrestler Uzile Prickett Had a VERY Bad Idea
Hour 19: The American Heavyweight Championship
Hour 18: Clarence Whistler is Superhuman Apparently
Hour 17: Theobaud Bauer is Dead and There Was Much Rejoicing
Hour 16: Pioneer Era Africa
Hour 15: That Time H.M. Dufur Was Shot in the Face
Hour 14: G.W. Flagg Writes a Letter
Hour 13: Pioneer Era Minnesota
Hour 12: Pioneer Era Alabama
Hour 11: The Life and Times of Matsada Sorakichi
Hour 10: Farmer Burns, Cigarette Cards, Evan Lewis
Hour 9: Jack Carkeek Goes to Prison
Hour 8: Opera House Cup
Hour 7: John McMahon
Hour 6: William Richardson: Belted Champion
Hour 5: The Terrible Turk: Yusif Ismil
Hour 4: Duncan C. Ross Tells All
Hour 3: The Trial of William Muldoon
Hour 2: Viro “Black Sam” Small: Pioneer African American Wrestler
Hour 1: Abraham Lincoln verses Jack Armstrong