When It Was Cool Podcast-logo-black.png


The When It Was Cool Podcast from WhenItWasCool.com is a fun look back at retro pop culture. We discuss retro TV, retro movies, new movies with retro themes, toys, dolls, action figures, cartoons, pro wrestling history, life when we were kids, classic rock music, plus themes from the 1970s through the 1990s! Come join us!



The Burbs (1989) Retro Movie Review Podcast

Karl and Tonya from When It Was Cool review the 1989 Tom Hanks movie The Burbs! Somehow, despite seeing this movie at the movie rental store for years and years he had never seen it. This film is actually pretty great and very fun! Carrie Fischer, Corey Feldman, and a host of other familiar faces from the 1980s appear in this movie. This was a fun one and worth checking out!

Direct Link - https://traffic.libsyn.com/secure/whenitwascool/The_Burbs_1989.mp3


Dream Scenario (2023) Movie Review Podcast

Karl and Tonya from When It Was Cool sit down to discuss the strange and conflicting 2023 drama Dream Scenario starring Nicolas Cage. This bizarre movie presents a pretty novel storyline of an unremarkable teacher who begins appearing in the dreams of people all over the world in passive situations. He becomes a viral celebrity and soon the dreams take a darker turn. This all sounds amazing, but the movie seems to lose its sense of where it is going. Join us as we discuss this very odd film.

Direct Link - https://traffic.libsyn.com/secure/whenitwascool/Dream_Scenario_2023.mp3


From Dusk Til Dawn (1996) Retro Movie Review Podcast

Karl and Tonya return with a retro movie review from 1996. George Clooney, Quentin Tarantino, and others star in this bizarre movie which switches from being solid crime escape action movie into a B-Movie vampire film about halfway through. This is one weird movie. Parts of this movie are fantastic in both scope, story, and scenery, while parts of it were straight out of a direct to video monster movie. I dunno... let's talk about it.

Direct Link - https://traffic.libsyn.com/secure/whenitwascool/From_Dusk_Till_Dawn_1996.mp3


Batman in Order Podcast - Detective Comics Issue 31 - Episode 5

The fifth appearance of The Batman took place in the September 1939 issue of Detective Comics. Once again, Batman was featured on the cover and this adventure pitted him against a new foe: The Monk, a mysterious man dressed in a red cloak and hood who had as his heavy a giant gorilla. We discover something new about Bruce Wayne in this issue, he is engaged to a woman named Julie Madison who is hypnotized (along with others) by the Monk. This is the last Batman in Order Podcast which will appear on our free feed. Future Batman in Order Series shows will be available exclusively to our Patreon supporters.

Read the article - here

Direct Link - https://traffic.libsyn.com/secure/whenitwascool/05_Batman_in_Order_Detective_Comics_31.mp3


Wonka, Willy Wonka, and Charlie and the Chocolate Factory Reviews

Karl and Tonya review a trio of movies today on the When It Was Cool podcast. We discuss the classic 1971 Gene Wilder film Willy Wonka and the Chocolate Factory, the tremendous Tim Burton 2005 Charlie and the Chocolate Factory starring Johnny Depp, and the new prequel now streaming on Max- Wonka starring Timothee Chalmete. All three films are tremendous in their own way and the 1971 film was a staple of many childhoods. Come on a trip (both literal and figurative) with Karl and Tonya as we discuss these three great movies where the snozberries taste like snozberries.

Direct Link - https://traffic.libsyn.com/secure/whenitwascool/Willy_Wonka_Charlie_and_the_Chocolate_Factory.mp3


The Price is Right Retro TV Review Podcast

When It Was Cool listeners come on down! Karl and Tonya sit down to discuss one of the most iconic of game shows: The Price is Right! It seems like everyone's grandmother loved this show and was probably secretly crushing on Bob Barker. Hey, let's be honest, The Price is Right was a fun TV game show full of goofy gimmick games and way over valued stuff, but it was tons of fun. Don't forget to have your pet spayed or neutered too you geek.

Direct Link - https://traffic.libsyn.com/secure/whenitwascool/The_Price_is_Right.mp3


Batman in Order Podcast 04 - Detective Comics Issue 30

Today at WhenItWasCool.com we take a look at the fourth appearance chronologically of the Batman character from the pages of Detective Comics issue 30 Detective Comics issue 30 cover dated August 1939. These Batman in Order reviews are less about the creators, behind the scenes, and the process of it all, and more about the story of The Batman, the character, and how he has changed and evolved and often represented or stood against common conventions of the time. The fourth Batman story is part two of a two-part series about an antagonist called Doctor Death. Batman not only kills somebody again in this issue (his third kill) he largely does so intentionally.

Read the article -here 

Direct Link - https://traffic.libsyn.com/secure/whenitwascool/04_Batman_in_Order_Detective_Comics_30.mp3


Scrabble - Retro Board Game Review

I, Karl, am writing this description. Scrabble is the bane of my existence. Tonya schools me in it ever... single... game. I don't know why. I am literate. I have a decent vocabulary, but she beats me in almost every single game. Scrabble is part crossword puzzle, part chance, and a lot of strategy. Join Karl and Tonya from WhenItWasCool.com to talk about one of our board game favorites- Scrabble!

Direct Link - https://traffic.libsyn.com/secure/whenitwascool/Scrabble.mp3


Batman in Order Podcast 03 - Detective Comics Issue 29

The third appearance of The Batman took place in Detective Comics issue 29 which came out in July 1939. It begins a two-part story arch against a mad scientist type named Doctor Death and, for the first time since Batman debuted, he managed not to kill someone... yet. In this issue the purpose of Batman's utility belt is introduced, and we find out he has created a contraption to allow him to scale buildings. 

To read the article - click here.

Direct Link - https://traffic.libsyn.com/secure/whenitwascool/03_Batman_in_Order_Detective_Comics_29.mp3


Maverick (1994 and Original Series)

Karl and Tonya revisit and Old West favorite- Maverick! Played in the 1950's - 1962 by James Garner and in a 1994 feature movie by Mel Gibson (with a co-starring role with James Garner as well!) Maverick was a slick talking master poker player and gunslinger (and con man). Both Garner and Gibson brought a slick charisma to the role and both series are among some of the best westerns out there. Join Karl and Tonya from When It Was Cool as we discuss the great western property, Maverick!

Direct Link - https://traffic.libsyn.com/secure/whenitwascool/Maverick_1994_and_Original_Series_Review.mp3


Batman in Order Podcast 02 - Detective Comics Issue 28

We continue our chronological look at the appearances of The Batman in chronological order. The second appearance of Batman took place in the pages of Detective Comics issue 28 cover dated June 1939. Batman swings from building to building on a rope for the first time. Completely throws a dude off a building to his death all to solve a jewelry theft.

You can read the article at When It Was Cool - here 

Direct Link - https://traffic.libsyn.com/secure/whenitwascool/02_Batman_in_Order_Detective_Comics_28.mp3


Batman in Order Podcast 01 - Detective Comics Issue 27

Join When It Was Cool on this new series following the chronological history of The Batman from his debut in 1939 through history. This is not a documentary series about the creators and artists (though they are mentioned) but instead is a study of the character of the Batman himself and the changes he has gone through over the years. Episode one takes a look back to 1939 and the debut of Batman in the pages of Detective Comics.

You can read the article at When It Was Cool - here

Direct Link - https://traffic.libsyn.com/secure/whenitwascool/01_Batman_in_Order_Detective_Comics_27.mp3


Untold History of Marvel Comics (2013) Book Review Podcast

Another book review from Karl from When It Was Cool and this one is a great book about comic books called the Untold History of Marvel Comics. This is a tremendous book tracing the history of Marvel Comics from the Golden Age until the era of the Marvel Cinematic Universe. It seems that the reality behind the famous Marvel Bullpen was way different than depicted by Stan Lee in the pages of Marvel Comics. Instead of a bunch of artists brainstorming ideas, it was a cutthroat world of politics, backstabbing, and disrespect. This is a fantastic book looking at the characters you love and the creators who made them.

Direct Link - https://traffic.libsyn.com/secure/whenitwascool/Untold_History_of_Marvel_2013.mp3


All When It Was Cool Podcast Episodes pre-2024 are available exclusively on our Patreon page! Click here to see our back catalog of podcasts!