Return to WhenItWasCool.com Home Page

Open Letter to Marvel Comics... You're Doing Moon Knight Wrong

By:  Karl Stern (@wiwcool, @dragonkingkarl, karl@whenitwascool.com)

I am a Moon Knight fan.  Let me get that straight right out of the gate.  I do not think of Moon Knight as "Marvel's low rent Batman" because he isn't.  I also don't see Moon Knight as some exploration of mental illness character because he shouldn't be.  I have been a fan of Moon Knight since the 1970's and I still buy his comics today so if there is anyone that Marvel Comics should be listening to when it comes to Moon Knight it is me.  I am invested in the character and I care about the character.

Werewolf by night 32 - the first appearance of moon knight

Werewolf by night 32 - the first appearance of moon knight

I also firmly believe that Marvel Comics is doing Moon Knight wrong and has been for a long time.

That's not to say that everything Marvel is doing with the character is wrong.  I absolutely love the new "Mr. Knight" look.  I think it is a fabulous upgrade but let's step back in time and as I write this article on Halloween night I do so not unintentionally.

Moon Knight belongs not in the world of Marvel Superheroes fighting alongside Spider-Man or the Avengers, nor does he belong stuck in the vigilante-verse with The Punisher.  He belongs in a corner that has long been forgotten and ignored by Marvel- he belongs with the monsters.

When Moon Knight debuted his first appearance wasn't in Spider-Man nor Fantastic Four nor The Hulk.  His debut took place in the long defunct Werewolf by Night.  He was a werewolf fighter.  His costume, though often depicted as white, was actually original envisioned as silver- as in silver to fight off werewolves.

After Moon Knight got his first solo series in the early 1980's the fantastic Bill Sienkiewicz art was eerily dark and brooding.  I suppose that also helped draw the comparisons to DC Comic's Batman.  There are similarities I admit: rich white guy (but that hardly puts them in a class by themselves), uses gadgets to fight crime, street level hero, and no super powers (or at least vaguely defined super powers.) 

Moon Knight's first series kept him fighting some supernatural critters like werewolves and zombies.

Moon Knight's first series kept him fighting some supernatural critters like werewolves and zombies.

But even in Moon Knights first series, which ran 38 issues, he began to stray away from werewolves and vampires and zombies by the end of the series.  

Moon Knight was brought back in 1985 with a re-emphasis on his Egyptian origins.  Moon Knight was, in origin, brought back to life by the Egyptian god of the night- Khonsu.  Though he was tricked out with new Egyptian themed gadgets his series abruptly ended after six issues.  He should have at least got to fight The Mummy during that time.

mid-1980's moon knight focused on his egyptian iconography.

mid-1980's moon knight focused on his egyptian iconography.

the long running Marc Spector:  Moon Knight started off promising.

the long running Marc Spector:  Moon Knight started off promising.

He was then brought back a few years later in his longest running series: Marc Spector:  Moon Knight.  This time, however, he was firmly poised as a super hero often fighting along side Spider-Man and the Punisher and other mainstream Marvel heroes.  He did, on occasion, bump into some scary monster-ish villains but that was hardly the main theme.

By the end of his series he had fallen into everything that made 1990's comic books largely horrible- techno armor and seriously over wrought artwork.

there is a lot going on in this picture.

there is a lot going on in this picture.

It seems that every few years a new Moon Knight series pops up.  The 2000's have mostly been spent exploring Moon Knight's "mental illness" which he shouldn't even have in the first place.  Moon Knight used multiple identities during his early days to battle crime such as the millionaire persona of Steven Grant or the taxi driver Jake Lockley.  Somewhere along the way some creator decided that using these multiple identities to battle crime equated to multiple personalities and most of the post-2000 series- including the current one- have been spent delving into that.

crazy... but that's how it goes.

crazy... but that's how it goes.

These explorations have been met mainly with indifference.  Although, I suppose we did get the super cool Mr. Knight outfit out of these largely forgettable series.

I say to Marvel Comics, it's time to return Moon Knight to his roots.  The Marvel Universe is sorely lacking in monsters, a long time staple of the industry.  We need a corner of the Marvel Universe where vampires, mummies, werewolves, and mad scientists roam.  Where the dead don't always remain dead.  It would be a cool place to explore the largely untouched zombie craze of the last ten years.  It would be a great place for staples like Dracula and the Werewolf and Morbius and other creatures of the night can strike fear into the nighttime traveler only to be protected by Mr. Knight.  Mr. Moon Knight that is.  

you can, however, keep this look.  mr. knight.

you can, however, keep this look.  mr. knight.

Put the silver back on Mr. Knight and go punch a vampire in the face.  That's the Moon Knight I want.  That's the Moon Knight we need.  Not another "is he crazy or is he not" story.  You can play with the full moon as a story device.  In the 1970's Moon Knight's strength ebbed and flowed with the phases of the moon.  That was a cool twist.  But it went away, replaced instead with rip off Batman gadgets.

I humbly implore you Marvel, give Moon Knight one more chance but this time let him go monster hunting.

We need you to keep WhenItWasCool.com growing.  We want to expand our podcasting network, team of writers, and expand our video channel.  In order to do that we need you to support us with one of the various membership levels at Patreon.  You'll get a TON of cool stuff daily- available only to you.  The higher your support level- the more cool stuff you will get.  Everything from digital comics to books to podcasts and audio documentaries.  Please take a moment to look at our Patreon page and please consider supporting us with a members package.  Thank you.